As a designer of massively complex systems I know it takes a few months at least to get a solid plan in place. Hence I am very puzzled when I hear smart men telling me we need to move fast or all will be lost. This feels like a play on my emotions, not the calm logical persuasion the right choice makes. Of course I want the right thing to happen, but I’m still not sold that the proposed plan is what we need.
So I read more details the stimulus plan and attempt to think for myself.
First I don’t like the focus on new homebuyers. This is mainly because I am not a first time homebuyer. I am a homeowner that needs help. Sure if I did specific work on my house I’ll get something back, but it’s still not as much if I was a 1st time buyer.
Secondly I’m worried about our government over spending in hopes of getting the people to do the same. When Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood said, “There aren't going to be any boondoggles. This money will be spent correctly, by the book, with no shortcuts,” I had to laugh as the US Government has never misspent funds before.
Thirdly I’m unimpressed with our Presidents arguments for his plan. “I reject that theory,” Mr. Obama said, “and so did the American people when they went to the polls in November and voted resoundingly for change”. Umm then why are you hitting the road to sell your idea to those very American people who voted for you? I guess I’m just looking for less of a ‘know-it-all’ leader and more of a guy who looks at all the angles. The people are worried; I am extremely worried, yet a quick fix may be a devil even worse then the old.
I’m not trying to be anti Obama here, that’s not what this is about. I worked at too many start-ups with cowboy directors who were 100% sure that their way was the only way. These were people I liked, guys I admired too, but when they refused to listen & learn from their oppositions even I had a hard time supporting them. And where are these cowboys now? I don’t know because the company folded.
Call me a libertarian, but I am always skeptical of my government trying to swoop in like superman and “save’ me from myself. I’m even more skeptical when my government does this for other people with less personal responsibility instilled them.
